“…NSA-style wholesale surveillance data-mining systems are useless for finding terrorists”

Bruce Schneier writes about how mass surveillance is not an effective way to find terrorists:

"No matter how sophisticated and super-duper are NSA’s methods for identifying terrorists, no matter how big and fast are NSA’s computers, NSA’s accuracy rate will never be 100% and their misidentification rate will never be 0%. That fact, plus the extremely low base-rate for terrorists, means it is logically impossible for mass surveillance to be an effective way to find terrorists…

Suppose that there are 1,000 terrorists there as well, which is probably a high estimate. The base-rate would be 1 terrorist per 300,000 people. In percentages, that is .00033%, which is way less than 1%. Suppose that NSA surveillance has an accuracy rate of .40, which means that 40% of real terrorists in the USA will be identified by NSA’s monitoring of everyone’s email and phone calls. This is probably a high estimate, considering that terrorists are doing their best to avoid detection. There is no evidence thus far that NSA has been so successful at finding terrorists. And suppose NSA’s misidentification rate is .0001, which means that .01% of innocent people will be misidentified as terrorists, at least until they are investigated, detained and interrogated. Note that .01% of the US population is 30,000 people…"

Be Sociable, Share!

• 

Related posts:

1. NSA Tentacles in Microsoft Vista
2. Britain wants to increase video surveillance of drivers
3. Government to data mine social networking web sites
4. Pentagon is getting sued by the New York Times
5. RFID passports arriving; kidnappers, theives and terrorists smile in anticipation